APPLIES TO: All plans

I’m Heather Signorelli, a physician who has spent more than a decade on the business side of healthcare. Gavari explains how health coverage really works, so we can fix it.

When I set up health benefits for my own company’s team, I saw a side of things I didn’t see as an employee. On a pay stub, health insurance is one line: the amount taken out of your check. For the average family with coverage through work, that’s $7,471 a year in 2026. However, the actual full cost of that same plan is over $28,000. [1] Your employer pays the rest, about $21,000, and it’s something we all forget about when we are employees. [2]

So essentially, the number most of us think of as “what health insurance costs” is about a quarter of the real price. And that’s only the first part of the money we don’t see.

Where to find your own numbers

For those of you who want to check your own contribution to your healthcare, take a look at your monthly paycheck to see what is pulled out. If your employer files 250 or more W-2s, your W-2 also shows the full cost of your coverage, your share plus your employer’s, in Box 12 with the code “DD.” That number is there for information only, and it isn’t taxed. [3] Most people either never look or simply forget about it. I’d encourage you to find both this year, because the total may have actually increased and your portion may also be increasing.

Where your premium goes: the pool

Now let’s think about how that money is used when you or your company pay those premiums. As you can probably guess, when you pay a premium, it doesn’t sit in an account in your name. It goes into a pool with everyone else’s premiums in that plan, and the pool pays everyone’s claims. In any year, most people in the pool use little care, and a few use a lot. That’s how insurance works: the healthy help pay for the sick, knowing that next year it could be them who needs more care.

The law sets limits on how much an insurance company can keep. Insurers selling to individuals and small employers must spend at least 80% of premiums on medical care and quality improvement, and those selling to large employers must spend at least 85%. The rest can go to administration, marketing, and profit. If they spend less on care, they owe customers a rebate. [4] In 2025, insurers in the individual market spent an average of 93% of their premium income on claims. [5]

So how do the largest insurance companies still make so much money? The 80/20 rule only covers the insurance company itself. Many of the largest insurers also own physician groups, clinics, and pharmacy benefit managers, the companies that manage prescription drug benefits. When the insurer pays a company it owns, that payment still counts as “medical care” under the rule, even if some of it ends up as profit for the same parent company. [6] I’ll dig into insurer profits, and where they actually come from, in a future issue.

What happens when healthy people leave a plan?

Because there is a pool of money that is used by the payer, its price depends on who’s in it. Premiums are set once a year, in advance. Insurers file next year’s rates with state regulators in the spring and summer, based on who they expect to be in the pool. [7] If healthier people leave, the same claims get spread across fewer people, and the premium for everyone who stays goes up the following year. Plans can’t charge sick people more for being sick, so the increase falls on everyone in the pool, healthy and sick alike. [8]

That’s happening right now in the marketplace, where people buy their own coverage. After the extra federal subsidies ended at the end of 2025, healthier people were more likely to drop their coverage because it became too costly. In my opinion, and as a guess, those people who are healthy would rather pay out of pocket for the few appointments they have during the year. Insurers estimate that the sicker group left behind pushed 2026 premiums up by about four percentage points, and they expect about four more points in 2027. [9] People who still get a subsidy are mostly protected, because their subsidy rises with the premium. [10] People who pay full price feel every point of it. In this case, the care didn’t change, but who is in the pool is changing.

The cost we never see

Beyond your employer’s share, two more streams of money pay for coverage, and both are close to invisible.

The first is a tax break. The money your employer spends on your health insurance isn’t counted as taxable income. The Joint Committee on Taxation estimates that this costs about $240 billion in federal income taxes in 2026, which makes it one of the largest tax breaks in the country. [11] The Congressional Budget Office puts the total at about $471 billion when payroll taxes are counted too. [12] Taxpayers effectively share the cost of every employer health plan, including yours.

The second is the marketplace subsidy. For people who buy their own coverage and qualify, the government sends the subsidy directly to their insurance company each month, so their bill is lower. [13] The enrollee sees a smaller bill. They never see the payment itself. Those subsidies cost about $105 billion in 2026. [11]

What this looks like in practice

As a physician, this is where it gets frustrating. A patient sees the $7,471 that comes out of their paycheck, then meets a deductible at the front desk and feels like they’re paying for everything twice. They usually don’t know that their employer and taxpayers are paying most of the premium, or that the insurer in the middle decides what gets covered. The practice ends up having the hardest conversations, helping the patient understand their plan when the practice is just the care delivery vehicle.

The other side

I am trying to stay fair in all of the articles we write, and I want to be fair in this issue as well. Pooling money is the point of insurance. Without it, one serious illness could ruin a family, and so much of disease or illness is unplanned. Most premium dollars do go to care: the 93% figure above is from the insurers’ own required reporting, and the rebate rule returns money when they fall short. [4] [5] And supporters of the tax break say it’s a big reason most working families can get coverage through their jobs at all. Critics argue it hides the real cost of care and gives the biggest benefit to people with the most expensive plans. Both are true to a degree, which is why it’s worth understanding before anyone tries to change it.

What this tells us about fixing it

What this tells me is that we can’t fix a system we can’t follow the money through. The person paying the premium, the person paying the subsidy, and the person receiving the care are rarely the same, and none of them can see the whole picture. If every patient saw the full premium, every employer saw how much of it went to care, and every plan showed what it spent and denied, we’d finally be having the right conversation about cost.

What to do with this

Physicians and practice leaders: when a patient is frustrated about their deductible, it can help to explain that their premium is mostly paid by their employer and that the plan, not the practice, sets what they owe. That takes the anger off your front desk and puts the question where it belongs.

Employers: ask your plan or broker how much of your premium went to claims last year, and how much of that claims money was paid to companies the insurer owns. If you’re self-funded, ask for the same breakdown of your administrative fees.

One question to ask

“What does our plan cost in total each year, and how much of that does the company pay?”

Next

Next, I want to look at the laws that changed who pays for coverage, and what they never changed.

Things you should know

Employer health costs are on track to pass $20,000 per employee. (survey) Marsh’s national employer survey puts the average cost at $18,777 per employee in 2026, up 7.3%. Employers expect another 8.2% in 2027. Fewer large employers now cover weight-loss GLP-1 drugs: 41%, down from 49% last year. Most employees will feel this as a bigger paycheck deduction or a higher deductible, not as a headline.

Only about 1 in 10 insurers say they’re ready for electronic prior authorization. (article) Starting January 1, 2027, Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and some marketplace plans must handle prior authorization, the insurer’s approval before care, electronically. In a WEDI survey, 17% of plans hadn’t started, and 62% said it’s costing more than they expected. Employer plans aren’t covered by this rule at all. That’s the gap I keep coming back to.

Humana says about 50,000 providers can skip prior authorization for some imaging and therapy. (article) Starting December 1, qualifying providers won’t need approval for MRI, CT, MRA, or physical and occupational therapy. Humana says it has cut about 11% of its prior authorizations. Rewarding physicians with a strong track record is a fair trade. The question is who scores that track record, and whether physicians can see their score.

States got six more months to enforce Medicaid work requirements. Nebraska turned it down. (article) The rules start in 44 states on January 1, 2027. On November 13, CMS let states delay enforcement until June 30, 2027. Nebraska, the first state to start, said it doesn’t need the extra time. A federal court also ruled in October that people who qualify as medically frail don’t have to prove a separate impairment to be exempt (summary). For practices, more patients may have Medicaid one month and not the next. Checking eligibility at every visit matters more in 2027.

Marketplace benchmark premiums are up 13% on average for 2027. (analysis) KFF reports 11% in HealthCare.gov states and 16% in states that run their own marketplace. The Congressional Budget Office projects enrollment will fall from 22.4 million in 2025 to 13.1 million in 2027. This is the pool effect from this week’s issue, happening in real time.

Help more people see how this works. If this issue helped you, forward it to one colleague, practice leader, or employer who should read it. If someone forwarded it to you, you can subscribe free at gavari.co.

And if you have a story about a denial, a delay, or a coverage rule nobody could explain, reply and tell me. Please leave out names and anything that could identify a patient.

Sources

  1. KFF, “Workers Now Pay $7,471 on Average Annually for Family Health Coverage, Up 9% or $621 from 2025” (Oct. 22, 2026): kff.org

  2. Becker’s Payer Issues, “Employees pay 9% more for family coverage in 2026: KFF” (employer contribution of $20,833): beckerspayer.com

  3. IRS, “Form W-2 Reporting of Employer-Sponsored Health Coverage”: irs.gov

  4. HealthCare.gov, “Rate Review & the 80/20 Rule”: healthcare.gov

  5. KFF, “2026 Medical Loss Ratio Rebates” (July 13, 2026): kff.org

  6. Health Affairs Forefront, “How Insurers That Own Providers Can Game The Medical Loss Ratio Rules” (Sept. 29, 2025): healthaffairs.org

  7. Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, “How much and why ACA Marketplace premiums are going up in 2027” (2026): healthsystemtracker.org

  8. HealthCare.gov, “How insurance companies set health premiums”: healthcare.gov

  9. KFF, “In Preliminary Rate Filings, ACA Marketplace Insurers Largely Propose Double-Digit Premium Increase for 2027” (July 2026): kff.org

  10. HR Executive, “ACA Marketplace insurers propose 14% premium hike for 2027” (KFF analysis): hrexecutive.com

  11. Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, “JCT Projects Tax Expenditures Will Be $2.3T in 2026”: crfb.org

  12. BenefitsPro, on CBO’s 2026 projections of federal subsidies for employer plans: benefitspro.com

  13. HealthCare.gov, “How to save on your monthly insurance bill with a premium tax credit”: healthcare.gov

Gavari does not take money from health insurers or health plans. If an issue has a sponsor, it is labeled at the top.

This is general education about how health coverage works. It is not insurance, legal, or medical advice. I do not sell insurance or recommend plans.

Have a question about how coverage rules work? Reply to this email. I read every reply. Please leave out personal medical details.